Estimate vs Quotation vs Proforma Invoice vs Tax Invoice: Legal Status & Conversion

By BillAmico Tax & Compliance Desk | | 12 min read

Shopkeepers use the words estimate, quotation, proforma invoice and bill almost as if they meant the same thing. Under GST they do not. Only a tax invoice creates a tax liability and lets your buyer claim input tax credit. The other three are offers or requests for payment, and mixing them up leads to wrong GST collection, rejected credit and trouble on the road with goods. This guide, as on 10 November 2026, explains the legal status, the accounting, the rate-change risk and the right way to convert each into a tax invoice.

1. The four documents in one table

DocumentWhat it isCreates tax liability?Can the buyer claim ITC on it?Accounting entry
EstimateA rough price indication (kachha bill in everyday speech)NoNoNone
QuotationA formal price offer with terms and a validity dateNoNoNone
Proforma invoiceA preview of the invoice, usually sent to ask for advance payment, a customs clearance or a bank approvalNoNoNone
Tax invoiceThe document for an actual taxable supply (Section 31, Rule 46)YesYesSales, tax payable and customer account

ITC means Input Tax Credit: the GST a business pays on purchases that it can set off against the GST it collects. A buyer gets ITC only on a valid tax invoice or another prescribed tax-paying document (Section 16(2)(a) of the CGST Act). An estimate, quotation or proforma invoice is none of these.

2. What GST law says (and does not say)

The CGST Act and Rules define and regulate the tax invoice, bill of supply, vouchers, credit and debit notes and the delivery challan in Section 31, Section 34 and Rules 46 to 55A. They contain no definition of an estimate, a quotation or a proforma invoice. These are commercial documents, not statutory ones.

Because they are not statutory, a business is free to issue them. But they carry no tax effect: no tax is payable because you sent one, and no tax is collectible on one. GST becomes payable on the time of supply (Sections 12 to 14), which is normally linked to the issue of a tax invoice or the receipt of payment for services. Our time-of-supply guide is at /blog/time-of-supply-and-advance-receipts-gst-sections-12-13-14-guide.

The document set the law does list for goods on the road is narrow. Under Rule 138A the person in charge of the vehicle must carry the invoice, bill of supply or delivery challan, as the case may be, together with the e-way bill. A proforma invoice is not on that list. No provision of the Act or Rules lists a proforma invoice as a transit document, so the safe position is that it cannot be used to move goods. If goods are moving without a sale, a delivery challan under Rule 55 is the right document. See /blog/gst-delivery-challan-rule-55-complete-guide.

warning: Do not collect GST against a proforma invoice and do not let the customer or transporter treat it as the bill. GST collected without a valid tax invoice, or on a document that is not an invoice, creates disputes with the buyer and with the department.

3. Estimate and quotation: purpose, content and validity

An estimate is an informal approximate price, often handwritten or printed from the billing machine. A quotation is a more formal offer: it names the goods, quantity, unit price, whether GST is extra or included, delivery terms, payment terms and a validity period.

A good quotation states clearly:

  • Your name, address and GSTIN, and the customer name.
  • A quotation number and date.
  • Item description, HSN code (the goods classification code) and quantity.
  • Unit price before tax, and GST at the rate known on the quotation date.
  • The validity period, for example 15 days from the date of issue.
  • A note such as: this is a quotation and not a tax invoice.
  • A rate-change clause: taxes will be charged as applicable on the date of supply.

In law, a quotation is an invitation to deal. When the customer accepts it, a contract may be formed, but only on the terms you wrote. If you promised a firm price without a validity date or without the tax clause, you may have to honour it even after a cost increase. The tax itself is never fixed by the quotation: the tax rate on the invoice is always the rate that applies on the date of supply (see Section 6).

4. Proforma invoice: what it is and where it is genuinely useful

A proforma invoice looks like a tax invoice but is issued before the supply. It is useful when the customer needs a document to arrange an advance, to apply for a bank loan or letter of credit, to obtain an import permit, or to get internal approval before paying.

It should be clearly marked at the top as PROFORMA INVOICE, NOT A TAX INVOICE, carry its own number series (separate from the tax invoice series so that your invoice numbers stay consecutive), and state the expected taxes only as an estimate.

What a proforma invoice cannot do:

  • It cannot be used by the buyer to claim ITC.
  • It cannot replace the tax invoice when goods move, or satisfy Rule 138A on the road.
  • It does not itself trigger GST liability, but a payment received against it does need a receipt voucher in the cases explained in Section 7.
  • It should not be reported in GSTR-1 as a sale.

5. Accounting treatment: which of these create entries

Estimates, quotations and proforma invoices are memorandum records. They create no sales, no receivable, no stock movement and no tax liability. Posting them to the books overstates sales and creates tax you may have to reverse. In a good system they are tracked in a separate register and are only converted when the deal is final.

Entries start in these cases:

EventDocumentAccounting effect
Quotation sentQuotationNone
Customer acceptsSales order or purchase order from customerNone (it is a commitment, not a sale)
Advance receivedReceipt voucherBank debit, customer advance (liability) credit, plus tax payable for services
Goods suppliedTax invoiceSales, tax payable, customer account
Goods moved without saleDelivery challanNone in sales; stock movement tracking only

Where goods are held with a customer on approval, the stock is still yours, and the challan only tracks it. Section 31(7) requires the invoice to be issued when the supply takes place or within six months of removal, whichever is earlier.

6. Rate-change risk: why the quotation date does not fix the GST rate

GST rates change by notification, as they did when the GST Council rationalised rates with effect from 22 September 2025. A quotation prepared before a change but converted to an invoice after the change does not keep the old rate. Section 14 of the CGST Act says that, when the rate changes, the time of supply decides which rate applies, and the time of supply is worked out from the dates of supply, invoice and payment.

For goods, a registered non-composition supplier pays tax at the time of supply determined by Section 12(2)(a), that is, the earlier of the invoice date and the last date on which the invoice should have been issued (Notification 66/2017-Central Tax). This notification also applies where Section 14 is attracted. In practice, an advance for goods does not lock the old rate, and the invoice side decides.

For services, an advance payment is itself a time of supply, so the part of the price paid before a rate change is taxed at the old rate, and the rest follows the invoice or the date of service.

The practical rule for your price lists: quote the price before tax, show the GST at the current rate, add a line that GST is as applicable on the date of supply, and refresh the quotation when a rate change is notified.

7. Advance against a proforma invoice: when a receipt voucher is needed

Customers often pay the proforma amount in advance. The moment money arrives, the position changes.

  • For a services advance, issue a receipt voucher (Section 31(3)(d), Rule 50) showing GST. The tax is payable for the month in which the advance is received.
  • For a goods advance, Notification 66/2017-Central Tax exempts regular taxpayers from paying tax on the advance. Section 31(3)(d) has not been amended, and issuing a receipt voucher with nil tax is the usual safe practice. Treat the nil-tax voucher as practice rather than a separately clarified rule.
  • If the deal falls through and you return the money, issue a refund voucher (Rule 51) quoting the receipt voucher.
  • Composition taxpayers do not collect GST, so for them the advance is a plain customer advance.

Whatever the type, record the advance as a liability to the customer (customer advance), not as sales. When the tax invoice is issued, the advance is adjusted against it.

The full set of voucher rules is explained at /blog/gst-documents-bill-of-supply-receipt-voucher-refund-voucher-payment-voucher-guide.

8. The conversion workflow: estimate to tax invoice

A clean path through the documents looks like this.

StepDocumentCheck before moving on
1Estimate or quotationValidity date, tax clause, correct HSN
2Customer order (sales order)Quantity, delivery date, payment terms agreed in writing
3Proforma invoice (optional)Marked not a tax invoice; sent only if the customer needs it to pay
4Receipt voucher (if advance)Tax treatment as per Section 7
5Delivery challan (only if goods move without sale, or in lots as required)Rule 55 details; ensure invoice follows
6Tax invoiceRate and date on the date of supply; place of supply; adjust the advance
7E-way bill (if value above ₹50,000 and goods move)Invoice or challan number matches

Never skip from quotation to delivery without a tax invoice. Under Section 31(1) the invoice for goods must be issued before or at the time of removal where goods move.

9. Worked examples

Example 1: rate change between quotation and invoice (goods). On 10 September 2025 a dealer quotes ₹1,00,000 plus 12 per cent GST for an item. The customer orders and pays an advance of ₹50,000 on 15 September. A notification then moves the item to 5 per cent from 22 September 2025. The dealer delivers and issues the tax invoice on 25 September. The customer paid no GST on the advance, because for goods the advance is exempt from tax for regular taxpayers, and the time of supply is the invoice date, so 5 per cent applies.

ItemAmount (Rs)
Taxable value1,00,000
CGST at 2.5 per cent2,500
SGST at 2.5 per cent2,500
Invoice total1,05,000
Less advance already received50,000
Balance payable by customer55,000

Using the quoted rate of 12 per cent would have charged ₹12,000 of tax instead of ₹5,000, and the customer could claim ITC only on the correct tax. Entries for the invoice:

AccountDebit (Rs)Credit (Rs)
Customer account1,05,000-
Sales-1,00,000
CGST payable-2,500
SGST payable-2,500
Customer advance50,000-
Customer account-50,000

Example 2: goods on approval. A garment shop sends 10 shirts at ₹1,000 each to a customer on approval on 1 October, with a delivery challan, no sale. On 12 October the customer keeps 6 shirts. The shop issues a tax invoice for 6 shirts, because the supply takes place on acceptance (Section 31(7)), and the 4 returned shirts are booked back by the challan. Taxable value ₹6,000, GST at 5 per cent for illustration = ₹300 (CGST ₹150 and SGST ₹150), total ₹6,300.

AccountDebit (Rs)Credit (Rs)
Customer account6,300-
Sales-6,000
CGST payable-150
SGST payable-150

Example 3: advance for services across a rate change (illustrative figures, not an actual notification). A consultant quotes ₹40,000 plus 12 per cent GST. The client pays ₹20,000 as advance on 15 March, and the rate moves to 18 per cent from 1 April. Services are completed and invoiced on 20 April. The consultant treats the advance as taxable at the old rate and the balance at the new rate. A tax-exclusive advance of ₹20,000 carries 12 per cent tax of ₹2,400; the balance of ₹20,000 carries 18 per cent tax of ₹3,600; total tax ₹6,000 on a price of ₹40,000, and the final invoice is for ₹46,000, of which ₹22,400 was already received.

AccountDebit (Rs)Credit (Rs)
Bank (receipt voucher, 15 March)22,400-
Customer advance-20,000
Tax payable on advance-2,400
Customer account (invoice, 20 April)46,000-
Service income-40,000
Tax payable-6,000
Customer advance20,000-
Tax payable on advance2,400-
Customer account-22,400

Note that the tax payable on the invoice (₹6,000) includes the ₹2,400 already paid on the advance, so only ₹3,600 is the additional liability when the invoice is issued. The details of the Section 14 outcome for each date combination are in the time-of-supply guide.

10. Common mistakes and consequences

  • Charging GST on a proforma invoice and keeping the money without a tax invoice or receipt voucher.
  • Moving goods against a proforma invoice or an estimate. Use a tax invoice or a delivery challan, as the case may be.
  • Sharing a single number series between proforma and tax invoices, which creates gaps in the invoice sequence.
  • Honouring an old quotation rate and ignoring a GST rate change, or the opposite.
  • Posting estimates as sales, which inflates turnover and tax.
  • Forgetting that an expired quotation is no longer binding.
  • Not adjusting the advance against the final invoice.

Issuing an invoice without a supply, or supplying without an invoice, is penalised under Section 122(1) of the CGST Act at the higher of ₹10,000 or the tax involved, and late tax carries interest at 18 per cent a year under Section 50.

11. Checklist and how BillAmico handles it

  • Mark every estimate, quotation and proforma with the words NOT A TAX INVOICE.
  • Put a validity date and a rate-change clause on every quotation.
  • Keep separate number series for proforma and tax invoices.
  • Issue a receipt voucher for every advance, and a refund voucher if you refund it.
  • Re-check the HSN and GST rate when converting an old quotation.
  • Use a tax invoice, a bill of supply or a delivery challan to move goods.

How BillAmico helps: the Estimates module (Alt+E) holds quotations as non-inventory, non-accounting documents, so they do not touch stock, sales or tax. When the customer confirms, Convert to Invoice brings the lines and customer details across to a new invoice draft. The invoice is a fresh document with its own date, so check the rate and tax on each line before saving, especially after a rate change. Delivery challans are in Alt+H and invoices in Alt+V.

Frequently asked questions

Is a proforma invoice a valid tax invoice under GST?

No. A proforma invoice is a preview document with no tax effect. GST law recognises only the tax invoice, bill of supply, vouchers and notes listed in Section 31 and Rules 46 to 55A. A buyer cannot claim input tax credit on a proforma invoice, and it should not be reported as a sale in GSTR-1.

Can I collect GST on a quotation or proforma invoice?

You should not collect GST on a quotation. If a customer pays an advance against a proforma invoice, you must issue a receipt voucher, and for services the GST on the advance is payable in the month of receipt. For goods, regular taxpayers are exempt from tax on the advance until the tax invoice is issued.

Can I send goods with a proforma invoice and an e-way bill?

Rule 138A requires the vehicle to carry an invoice, a bill of supply or a delivery challan along with the e-way bill. A proforma invoice is not on that list. For a supply, issue a tax invoice before dispatch. For movement without a sale, issue a delivery challan under Rule 55.

Which GST rate applies if the rate changes after my quotation?

The rate applicable on the time of supply under Sections 12 to 14 applies, not the rate on the quotation date. For goods, regular taxpayers pay tax at the time of supply set by Section 12(2)(a), usually the invoice date. A quotation should therefore say that GST will be charged as applicable on the date of supply.

Does an estimate create any accounting entry or tax liability?

No. An estimate or quotation is a memorandum document. It creates no sale, receivable, stock movement or tax liability. Accounting entries begin only with an advance receipt, a tax invoice or a delivery challan stock movement, so estimates should be kept out of the sales ledger.

How long should a quotation stay valid?

GST law sets no period, so it is a commercial choice. Fifteen to thirty days is common for goods, and shorter for items with unstable prices. State the validity date on the quotation and add that taxes are as applicable on the date of supply, so a rate change does not bind you to the old tax.

Official sources

Related guides