Estimate, Quotation and Proforma Invoice: History, Meaning and Legal Status in India (With Exam Notes)
By BillAmico Tax & Compliance Desk | | 12 min read
Before a sale, there is usually a price conversation. The seller gives an estimate, a quotation or a proforma invoice, and the buyer decides. These three papers look similar, but in law and in accounting they are not the same, and none of them is a tax invoice. This guide explains each term, its word history, the Indian legal position on whether a quotation binds the seller, and what to remember for an exam.
1. The three documents in plain words
| Document | What it is | Binding? | Accounting entry? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimate | An approximate cost, often for work whose final cost is unknown | Usually not binding, the final bill may differ | No |
| Quotation | A specific price offered for stated goods or services, often valid for a period | Depends on wording; see the legal section below | No |
| Proforma invoice | A preliminary invoice sent before supply, used for advance payment, bank or customs purposes | Not a tax invoice | No sale is recorded |
None of the three creates a sale, revenue or tax liability. Stock is not reduced and no customer account is posted. A tax invoice is issued only when the supply is actually made.
2. Where the words come from
Estimate comes from the Latin aestimare, to value or appraise. Quotation comes from the Latin quotare, to mark or number, which gave the sense of quoting a figure. Proforma is Latin for as a matter of form: a document prepared for form, not final.
These are dictionary-level origins and are widely accepted. We found no reliable record of when an estimate, quotation or proforma first appeared as a standard trade paper. Merchants have always quoted prices before trading, so no inventor or first date can be named.
3. Legal status: proposal or invitation to treat?
Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contract needs a proposal (offer) and its acceptance. Section 2(a) defines a proposal as a person signifying to another a willingness to do or abstain from doing something, with a view to obtaining the other's assent. When the other person accepts, the proposal becomes a promise (Section 2(b)), and a promise that is legally enforceable is a contract.
The key question is whether a quotation is a proposal or only an invitation to make one. An invitation to treat is a step before an offer. It invites the other side to make an offer, so acceptance of it does not itself create a contract.
The classic English case is Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552, decided by the Privy Council on an appeal from Jamaica. Harvey telegraphed asking if Facey would sell a property and for the lowest price. Facey replied giving a price. The Privy Council held that stating a lowest price was a mere statement of price, not an offer to sell, so Harvey's reply of acceptance did not make a contract.
The Indian Supreme Court applied the same reasoning in Col. D. I. MacPherson v M. N. Appanna (1951 SCR 161). A statement that the seller would not accept less than a stated sum was held to be a statement of the minimum price, not an offer. Commentaries also cite Pharmaceutical Products of India v Gwalior Chemical Works (1960) for the view that a price list is an invitation to treat. These case summaries come from secondary sources, so students should read the reported judgments before quoting them in detail.
warning: Practical caution: a quotation that is firm, specific, says it is valid until a date and says "we offer" can be read as a real offer. Courts look at wording and intention, so write quotations carefully.
4. Proforma invoice: uses and limits
A proforma invoice is prepared before supply. Common uses are asking a buyer to pay an advance, helping a buyer arrange a bank payment or letter of credit, and supporting customs or import steps.
A proforma invoice is not a tax invoice. A buyer cannot claim input tax credit on it, and a seller does not record sales on it. When an advance is received, GST law requires a receipt voucher, and when the supply is made, a tax invoice follows.
5. Conversion workflow
A clean flow is: estimate or quotation, then buyer confirmation, then (optionally) proforma invoice for advance, then the supply with a delivery challan if needed, and finally the tax invoice.
Keep the quotation number on the final invoice. This gives a clear paper trail if the buyer later disputes the agreed price.
tip: In BillAmico, Estimates (press E, or Alt + E in a field) are non-accounting price quotations that convert to a tax invoice in one click when the customer agrees.
6. Timeline of the legal position
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1872 | Indian Contract Act, 1872: Section 2(a) defines proposal |
| 1893 | Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552: lowest price statement is not an offer |
| 1951 | MacPherson v Appanna (1951 SCR 161): Supreme Court applies the same rule |
| 1960 | Pharmaceutical Products of India v Gwalior Chemical Works: price list as invitation to treat (as cited in commentaries) |
| 1 July 2017 | GST: proforma invoice and quotation are not tax invoices; Section 31 governs the tax invoice |
7. Quick revision for exams
- Estimate, quotation and proforma invoice do not record a sale or any accounting entry.
- Proposal: Section 2(a), Indian Contract Act, 1872. Acceptance makes it a promise (Section 2(b)).
- An invitation to treat is not an offer. A price list or a statement of lowest price is usually an invitation to treat.
- Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552 (Privy Council); MacPherson v Appanna (1951 SCR 161).
- Proforma invoice is not a tax invoice and gives no ITC.
- Words: estimate from aestimare (to value), quotation from quotare, proforma means as a matter of form.
Model question. Q: Is a price quotation an offer? A: Ordinarily it is an invitation to treat, but a quotation that is specific, firm and capable of acceptance may be treated as a proposal. The wording decides.
Frequently asked questions
Is a quotation legally binding in India?
Not automatically. A price list or general statement of price is normally an invitation to treat, not an offer. A specific, firm quotation capable of acceptance may amount to a proposal under Section 2(a) of the Indian Contract Act, depending on its wording.
What is the difference between an estimate and a quotation?
An estimate is an approximate cost and may change. A quotation states a specific price for stated goods or services, often valid for a period.
Is a proforma invoice a tax invoice?
No. It is a preliminary document. A buyer cannot claim input tax credit on it, and the seller does not record a sale until a tax invoice is issued.
What did Harvey v Facey decide?
The Privy Council held in 1893 that stating the lowest price at which a property would be sold was not an offer, so the buyer's acceptance did not create a contract.
Do estimates and quotations affect the books of accounts?
No. They are not source documents for any entry. Accounting begins when a sale is made and a tax invoice is issued.