Closing Stock Valuation for Tax and Accounts: Lower of Cost or Net Realisable Value, Trading Account and Balance Sheet

By BillAmico Tax & Compliance Desk | | 12 min read

At the end of the year every trader must put a value on the goods still in the shop. That closing stock figure feeds the trading account, decides the gross profit and the tax, and appears on the balance sheet. A wrong figure changes the profit of two years. This guide explains the lower of cost or net realisable value rule, what goes into cost, and how closing stock flows through the accounts, with a worked example.

1. Why closing stock valuation matters

Cost of goods sold is not what you bought during the year. It is what you bought plus the stock you started with, minus the stock left at the end. So closing stock is a direct deduction from cost. A higher closing stock gives a lower cost of goods sold and a higher profit. A lower closing stock does the opposite.

The closing stock of one year is the opening stock of the next. An error therefore moves profit in two years in opposite directions. If closing stock is overstated by Rs 6,000 this year, profit is overstated by Rs 6,000 this year and understated by Rs 6,000 next year, other things being equal.

Both the income tax authorities and auditors look closely at stock, because it is easy to adjust and hard to verify. A consistent, documented method protects you.

2. The basic rule: lower of cost and net realisable value

The accepted rule is that stock is valued at cost or net realisable value, whichever is lower. This follows the principle of prudence: do not count a profit that has not been earned, but do recognise a loss as soon as it is expected.

Cost means what the goods cost you to bring to their present location and condition. Net realisable value (NRV) means the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less the estimated costs needed to make the sale, such as packing or commission.

TermMeaning
CostPurchase price plus costs to bring the goods to the shop
Net realisable valueExpected selling price minus the cost of selling
Closing stock valueThe lower of cost and NRV, item by item

The Indian accounting standard on inventories is AS 2, issued by ICAI. For income tax computation, Income Computation and Disclosure Standard (ICDS) II covers valuation of inventories and follows the same lower of cost or NRV approach. The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the 1961 Act from 1 April 2026 and renumbered its sections. Verify the current section and standard references on the income tax portal before citing them in an assessment.

info: A value cannot go above cost. Even if the market price is higher than what you paid, stock stays at cost. Only a fall below cost is recognised.

3. What is included in cost and what is left out

Included in costLeft out of cost
Purchase priceTrade discounts and rebates (deducted from cost)
Freight inward and loading chargesSelling and distribution costs
Import duties and non-recoverable taxesGST that you can claim as input tax credit
Direct costs of bringing goods to the shopAbnormal wastage and storage costs not needed for production

GST that you can claim back as input tax credit is not a cost, because you recover it. If a tax credit is blocked or not available, the tax you paid is generally part of the cost of the goods. Check your ITC position item by item. Section 17(5) of the CGST Act lists blocked credits.

Do not include selling costs, such as the salesman commission or advertising, in cost. They are expenses of the period. Normal storage and rent of the shop are expenses, not part of stock cost for a trader.

4. Choosing a cost formula: FIFO or weighted average

When identical goods are bought at different prices, you need a rule to decide which cost belongs to the closing stock. The standards accept first-in first-out (FIFO) and weighted average cost. LIFO (last-in first-out) is not accepted under AS 2 and ICDS II.

FIFO assumes the oldest goods are sold first, so closing stock carries the latest purchase prices. Weighted average spreads the cost across all units on hand. When prices are rising, FIFO usually shows a higher closing stock and a higher profit than weighted average.

Once you choose a method, apply it consistently from year to year. A change of method needs a good reason and a clear disclosure. The comparison of the two methods, with a working example, is in the FIFO vs weighted average guide on this site.

BillAmico lets you select the stock costing method (FIFO or Weighted Average) in Accounts settings, and the stock reports follow that choice.

5. Worked example: valuing closing stock item by item

A trader counts four product groups at year end. Cost is from purchase records. NRV is the expected selling price less selling costs.

ItemCostNRVValue taken (lower)
Group ARs 50,000Rs 62,000Rs 50,000
Group BRs 30,000Rs 24,000Rs 24,000
Group CRs 20,000Rs 20,000Rs 20,000
Group DRs 10,000Rs 12,500Rs 10,000
TotalRs 1,10,000Rs 1,18,500Rs 1,04,000

Group B is the only one where NRV is below cost, so it is written down by Rs 6,000. Group A and Group D are held at cost even though they could sell for more. The closing stock figure is Rs 1,04,000.

Note that the rule is applied item by item, or by groups of similar items. If you compared only the totals, cost Rs 1,10,000 against NRV Rs 1,18,500, you would keep Rs 1,10,000 and miss the Rs 6,000 loss on Group B. This is why item-wise valuation is the safer practice.

The write-down is passed through the books as a reduction in closing stock. In the trading account it simply shows as the lower closing stock figure.

6. How closing stock flows into the trading account

Continue the example with the following year figures: opening stock Rs 80,000, purchases Rs 6,00,000, purchase returns Rs 10,000, freight inward Rs 15,000, sales Rs 8,00,000, sales returns Rs 20,000 and closing stock Rs 1,04,000.

ParticularsAmount
Opening stockRs 80,000
Add: Purchases less returns (6,00,000 - 10,000)Rs 5,90,000
Add: Freight inwardRs 15,000
Goods available for saleRs 6,85,000
Less: Closing stockRs 1,04,000
Cost of goods soldRs 5,81,000
Net sales (8,00,000 - 20,000)Rs 7,80,000
Gross profit (7,80,000 - 5,81,000)Rs 1,99,000

Gross profit is Rs 1,99,000, which is about 25.51 percent of net sales. Had closing stock been taken at the total cost of Rs 1,10,000, gross profit would show Rs 2,05,000. The extra Rs 6,000 would be a profit on paper that is not supported by the shelf, because Group B cannot be sold for what it cost.

Closing stock then also appears on the balance sheet. Under Schedule III to the Companies Act it is shown among current assets as inventories, and sole proprietors and firms show it as a current asset in the same way.

7. Stock counts, losses and good record-keeping

A physical count at the year end is the starting point. Count every item, record the quantity and tie it to the stock register. Investigate differences instead of adjusting silently.

Stock that is damaged, expired or slow-moving needs special attention. If it can only be sold at a loss, it should be valued at NRV. Expired goods may have no realisable value and may be written off fully.

Be careful with GST on stock that is lost, stolen, destroyed or written off. Section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act blocks input tax credit on goods lost, stolen, destroyed, written off or given away as gifts or free samples, so credit already taken needs to be reversed. Discuss each case with your CA.

  • Keep dated count sheets signed by the persons who counted.
  • Value item by item and keep the working.
  • Use the same cost formula every year.
  • Record write-downs with the reason for them.
  • Reconcile the stock register to the books at each year end.

BillAmico stock summary and stock ledger reports show quantity and value by item, which gives a starting list for the count.

warning: Do not adjust closing stock only to change the profit. A deliberate under or over valuation is a tax and audit risk, and the next year automatically reverses the effect.

8. Quick revision checklist

  • Closing stock is valued at the lower of cost and NRV.
  • Cost includes purchase price and costs to bring goods to the shop. It excludes recoverable GST and selling costs.
  • FIFO and weighted average are accepted. LIFO is not accepted under AS 2 and ICDS II.
  • Apply the method consistently. Disclose any change.
  • Gross profit equals net sales minus (opening stock plus net purchases plus direct costs minus closing stock).
  • Overstated closing stock overstates this year profit and understates the next.
  • On the balance sheet, closing stock is a current asset (inventories).

Frequently asked questions

How is closing stock valued for income tax and accounts?

At cost or net realisable value, whichever is lower, generally item by item. This follows AS 2 for accounts and ICDS II for income tax computation. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, section numbers have changed, so check the current references on the income tax portal.

What is net realisable value?

It is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less the estimated costs of making the sale. If NRV is below cost, the stock is written down to NRV.

Is GST part of the cost of stock?

Not where you can claim the GST as input tax credit, because you recover it. If the credit is blocked or not available, the tax paid is generally part of the cost. Check the credit position for each purchase.

Can I use LIFO to value my closing stock?

No. LIFO is not accepted under AS 2 or ICDS II. Use FIFO or weighted average and apply the same method every year.

What happens if closing stock is overstated?

Cost of goods sold falls, so gross profit and net profit rise for that year. The same stock becomes next year's opening stock, so next year's profit falls by the same amount. The error reverses itself, but it can cause excess tax in one year and questions from an auditor or officer.

Official sources

Related guides