Bad Debts, Provision for Doubtful Debts, Trade Discount and Cash Discount: Accounting Entries and GST Section 15(3)

By BillAmico Tax & Compliance Desk | | 12 min read

Almost every shopkeeper sells on credit (udhaar) and almost every shopkeeper gives some discount. Both create entries that confuse new accountants and students: when to write off a debt, whether to keep a provision, why a trade discount is never recorded in the books while a cash discount is, and how GST treats a discount given after the invoice. This guide explains bad debts, provision for doubtful debts, trade discount and cash discount with journal entries and a worked example, and then covers the GST rule on discounts in Section 15(3) of the CGST Act 2017. The position is stated as on 11 November 2026, and income tax section numbers are given for the 1961 Act, with a note that the Income-tax Act 2025 has renumbered them.

1. Bad debts, provision for doubtful debts and discounts: why they matter

Credit sales raise profit on paper but not cash in hand. When a customer does not pay, the profit shown in the books is overstated. Accounting therefore asks the business to recognise two things: a debt that is certainly lost, which is a bad debt, and a debt that may be lost, which is a doubtful debt for which a provision is made. This follows the idea of prudence: do not count a gain until it is reasonably certain, but provide for a loss as soon as it is likely.

Discounts raise a different question. A reduction in price at the time of sale is a trade discount and simply lowers the price. A reduction for early payment is a cash discount and is a separate financial item. The two are treated differently in accounts and, since 2017, also in GST.

ItemWhat it meansWhere it appears
Bad debtA customer balance that cannot be recovered and is written offProfit and loss account (expense)
Provision for doubtful debtsAn estimate of the dues that may not be recoveredProfit and loss (expense) and deducted from debtors on the balance sheet
Trade discountReduction from list price at the time of saleNot recorded; the invoice shows the net price
Cash discount allowedReduction given to a customer for prompt paymentProfit and loss account (expense)
Cash discount receivedReduction obtained from a supplier for prompt paymentProfit and loss account (income)

2. Bad debts: meaning, journal entries and recovery

A bad debt is a sum owed by a customer that the business decides it cannot recover, for example because the customer has closed down, absconded, become insolvent, or a legal claim has failed. The decision should be made by the owner or a senior manager after reminders, a notice and a record of what was tried. A written note of the reason supports the entry for audit and tax.

Entry on writing off the debt: Dr Bad Debts, Cr Customer account. The Bad Debts account is an expense and is transferred to the profit and loss account at year end. The customer account is closed.

Example: Rajesh Traders owes the shop ₹50,000 from an invoice raised in 2025. After reminders and a legal notice, the shop concludes that the amount is irrecoverable. The entry is Dr Bad Debts 50,000, Cr Rajesh Traders 50,000.

Recovery later: if the customer pays a part later, the entry is Dr Bank 4,000, Cr Bad Debts Recovered 4,000. The amount is income of the year in which it is received. Do not reopen the old customer account or the old year's books.

A written-off debt does not mean the debt is forgiven in law. The shop can still sue within the limitation period, and the customer still owes the money, but the books no longer show the amount as an asset.

3. Provision for doubtful debts: an ageing worked example

A provision is a charge to profit for a loss that is likely but not yet certain. The shop sets aside an amount on the strength of experience. There are two common methods: a flat percentage on the closing debtors, or an ageing schedule that applies a higher percentage to older dues. The ageing method is more accurate because the chance of recovery drops as a bill gets older.

Example: At 31 March 2027 the shop's debtors are ₹6,00,000 before any write-off. It writes off a bad debt of ₹10,000, leaving ₹5,90,000. The opening balance in the Provision for Doubtful Debts account is ₹20,000. The percentages below are for illustration and each shop should use its own experience.

Age of debtDebtors (₹)Provision rateProvision (₹)
0 to 30 days3,00,0001%3,000
31 to 60 days1,50,0003%4,500
61 to 90 days90,00010%9,000
Over 90 days50,00030%15,000
Total5,90,000-31,500

Required provision is ₹31,500 and the existing provision is ₹20,000, so ₹11,500 more must be charged. The entries are:

EntryDebit (₹)Credit (₹)
Bad Debts A/c10,000-
Customer (Debtors) A/c-10,000
Profit and Loss A/c (provision for doubtful debts)11,500-
Provision for Doubtful Debts A/c-11,500

The profit and loss charge for the year is ₹10,000 + ₹11,500 = ₹21,500. On the balance sheet, debtors are shown at ₹5,90,000 less the provision ₹31,500, which is a net figure of ₹5,58,500. If the required provision at the next year end is lower than the balance, the difference is written back as income.

info: The provision for doubtful debts does not reduce the customer's account. The customer still owes the full amount and your reminders continue. The provision only makes the balance sheet show a prudent value of debtors.

4. Income tax treatment of bad debts and provisions

The accounting entry and the tax rule are not the same. Under the Income-tax Act 1961, a bad debt is deductible under section 36(1)(vii), subject to section 36(2), if two conditions are met: the amount was taken into account as income in the year of the write-off or an earlier year, and it has been written off as irrecoverable in the books of account. The courts have held that after the 2016 amendment the taxpayer need not prove that the debt has actually become irrecoverable, but it must be written off in the books.

A general provision for doubtful debts is not allowed as a tax deduction for an ordinary business. It is added back when you compute taxable income, and the loss is allowed only when the debt is actually written off. Special provisions exist for banks and some financial companies. If a debt that was allowed as a deduction is recovered later, the amount is taxed as income of the year of recovery (section 41(4) of the 1961 Act).

A presumptive taxpayer, whose profit is a fixed percentage of turnover, does not claim bad debts separately because the deemed profit is the final figure. The Income-tax Act 2025 has renumbered these provisions, so verify the new section numbers on the portal. Ask your CA how to treat the GST part of a written-off invoice, since the answer depends on how the debt was taken into account in your income.

5. Trade discount versus cash discount

PointTrade discountCash discount
When givenAt the time of sale, on the list priceWhen the customer pays early
ReasonBulk purchase, dealer margin, festival offerEncourage prompt payment
Shown in booksNot recorded; only the net price is bookedRecorded as an expense or income
Shown on invoiceYes, as a deduction from the list priceUsually only as a terms line, such as 2/10 net 30
Effect on the account of the customerThe customer is debited with the net amountThe customer is credited with the full invoice value, and the discount is a separate entry
GST valueThe taxable value is the net price after discountDepends on Section 15(3), explained below

The words 2/10 net 30 are common on invoices: a 2% discount if paid in 10 days, otherwise the full amount in 30 days.

The accounting names are from the shop's point of view. A discount given to the customer is Discount Allowed, which is a loss for the shop. A discount obtained from a supplier is Discount Received, which is a gain.

6. Worked example: trade discount, cash discount and entries

A shop sells goods with a list price of ₹10,000 to a trader. It gives a trade discount of 10% and charges GST at 18%. The customer is offered a 2% cash discount on the invoice value for payment within 10 days, and the discount is agreed in writing before the sale.

StepWorkingAmount (₹)
List priceAs per price list10,000
Trade discount at 10%10,000 x 10%1,000
Taxable value on the invoice10,000 - 1,0009,000
GST at 18%9,000 x 18%1,620
Invoice total9,000 + 1,62010,620
Cash discount at 2% of the invoice value10,620 x 2%212.40
Customer pays within 10 days10,620 - 212.4010,407.60

The sale entry in the seller's books uses only the net price. The trade discount of ₹1,000 is not recorded anywhere: Dr Customer 10,620, Cr Sales 9,000, Cr Output GST 1,620.

When the customer pays early, the entry depends on whether the GST conditions in Section 15(3), explained in the next section, are met.

CaseSeller's entryBuyer's entry
Conditions met: discount of 180 plus 32.40 GSTDr Bank 10,407.60, Dr Discount Allowed 180, Dr Output GST 32.40, Cr Customer 10,620Dr Supplier 10,620, Cr Bank 10,407.60, Cr Discount Received 180, Cr Input GST 32.40 (credit reversed)
Conditions not met: GST unchangedDr Bank 10,407.60, Dr Discount Allowed 212.40, Cr Customer 10,620Dr Supplier 10,620, Cr Bank 10,407.60, Cr Discount Received 212.40

In both cases the debit total equals the credit total at ₹10,620 for the seller and ₹10,620 for the buyer. The difference between them is only the GST part: ₹32.40 of output tax and input credit reversed when the conditions are met.

7. GST Section 15(3): how a discount affects the value of supply

GST is charged on the transaction value, and Section 15(3) of the CGST Act 2017 says when a discount is excluded from that value. There are two cases.

  • A discount given before or at the time of supply is excluded if it is duly recorded in the tax invoice. This covers the usual trade discount printed on the bill.
  • A discount given after the supply is excluded only if both conditions are true: it is established under an agreement entered into at or before the time of supply and specifically linked to the relevant invoices, and the input tax credit attributable to the discount has been reversed by the recipient.

If the conditions are met, the supplier issues a credit note under Section 34 and reduces the tax liability. The time limit for a credit note is the 30th of November following the end of the financial year, or the date of filing the annual return, whichever is earlier. The recipient must reverse the proportionate input tax credit, as in the entries above. If the conditions are not met, for example because the discount was announced after the sale as a surprise scheme, the original value stays and the GST on it is not reduced. The CBIC has issued clarifications on post-sale discounts, so check the current circular before you decide the treatment of a particular scheme.

Two other GST rules link with this topic. First, GST law does not give a supplier a general bad debt relief: the tax is payable when the supply is made, and a later failure of the customer to pay does not by itself reduce it. A credit note under Section 34 is for goods returned, price revision, deficiency and similar causes, so do not issue one merely because the customer defaulted, and take your CA's advice on the exact position. Second, Rule 37 of the CGST Rules requires a buyer who has not paid a supplier within 180 days from the invoice date to reverse the input tax credit with interest, and to claim it again when the payment is made.

warning: A cash discount that is not agreed in advance or not linked to the invoices will not reduce the GST. If you give such a discount, record it as a loss in your books and do not issue a GST credit note for it.

8. Common mistakes and a monthly checklist

  • Recording a trade discount as an expense. It should not appear in the books at all, because the invoice already shows the net price.
  • Writing off a bad debt without a written reason, or without approval, which weakens both the audit and the tax claim.
  • Treating a provision as a bad debt and removing the customer from the ledger. The customer still owes the money.
  • Giving a post-sale discount without a prior written agreement and then issuing a credit note to cut the GST.
  • Ignoring the 180-day rule on purchases, which can force a reversal of input tax credit.

Monthly routine: run the receivables ageing report for 30, 60 and 90 days, send reminders for older bills, keep a note of each customer's response, recompute the provision at year end, and get approval for each write-off. BillAmico provides customer ledgers, a receivables ageing report and WhatsApp reminders, so the data for these entries is ready before you sit down with your accountant.

Frequently asked questions

What is the journal entry for bad debts?

Debit Bad Debts account and credit the customer account for the amount written off. At year end Bad Debts is transferred to the profit and loss account. If part of it is recovered later, debit Bank and credit Bad Debts Recovered, which is income.

What is the difference between bad debts and provision for doubtful debts?

A bad debt is an amount that is certainly lost and is written off against the customer account. A provision for doubtful debts is an estimate of the amount that may be lost. It is charged to profit and deducted from debtors on the balance sheet, but the customer accounts stay open.

Is trade discount recorded in the books of account?

No. A trade discount is a reduction in the list price at the time of sale, so only the net price is booked in the sales and purchase entries. A cash discount for early payment is recorded separately as Discount Allowed (expense) or Discount Received (income).

How does GST Section 15(3) treat a discount given after the sale?

A post-sale discount is excluded from the taxable value only if it was agreed at or before the supply and linked to the specific invoices, and the buyer reverses the input tax credit on it. The supplier then issues a credit note under Section 34 within the time limit.

Can a provision for doubtful debts be claimed as an income tax deduction?

For an ordinary business, no. A general provision is added back when computing taxable income, and a deduction is allowed only when the debt is written off as a bad debt in the books under section 36(1)(vii), subject to section 36(2). Banks and certain financial companies have special rules.

Official sources

Related guides